Glossary entry (derived from question below)
Sep 4, 2003 15:23
20 yrs ago
Russian term
суд чести
Russian to English
Science
Science (general)
A scientific institution is investigating an allegation of falsification of data and this body issues the findings.
"Court of honor" just sounds wrong for such a body, at least in the US. Is this simply "Board of Inquiry" or is there another,
commonly-used term in such organizations?
"Court of honor" just sounds wrong for such a body, at least in the US. Is this simply "Board of Inquiry" or is there another,
commonly-used term in such organizations?
Proposed translations
(English)
3 +2 | board of inquiry seems to be OK | Kirill Semenov |
3 +6 | Ethics Committee; Board of Ethics | xeni (X) |
4 | peer review board | Vladimir Pochinov |
3 | comrade's court or court of fellow workers | Сергей Лузан |
Proposed translations
+2
8 mins
Russian term (edited):
��� �����
Selected
board of inquiry seems to be OK
Here is a quote from a page "Scientific Misconduct":
The Chair of the VMI Research Committee will select a panel of tenured faculty members to serve as a Board of Inquiry. The Chair of the VMI Research Committee will conduct the procedures but will be an ex officio member. Individuals serving on the Board of Inquiry will be selected to avoid potential conflicts of interest. An individual may be excused by a majority vote of the Board upon the request of the individual under investigation. As necessary, the Chair of the Board of Inquiry will appoint a tenured member of the faculty to replace any individual so excused for the purposes of the investigation.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 23 mins (2003-09-04 15:47:17 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
More examples (basically, I\'ve searched Google using the string:
\"board of inquiry + scientific + misconduct\" and found more than 300 entries):
http://www.stthomasu.ca/research/Research/Researchintegrityp...
...
3. To determine that the substance of the allegation may be a serious act of misconduct and, establish a \"Board of Inquiry\" to conduct a formal investigation.
http://www.bcit.ca/~presoff/6600.htm
B. Investigating Allegations of Misconduct in Research
...
B.6.2 The Dean, Applied Research shall receive submissions and consult with whatever other parties he/she deems necessary, and within 30 days of receiving the Respondent\'s submission shall submit a report to the Vice-President recommending whether or not the Complaint should proceed to a formal Board of Inquiry. Copies of the Dean\'s report shall be made available to the Complainant and Respondent.
The Chair of the VMI Research Committee will select a panel of tenured faculty members to serve as a Board of Inquiry. The Chair of the VMI Research Committee will conduct the procedures but will be an ex officio member. Individuals serving on the Board of Inquiry will be selected to avoid potential conflicts of interest. An individual may be excused by a majority vote of the Board upon the request of the individual under investigation. As necessary, the Chair of the Board of Inquiry will appoint a tenured member of the faculty to replace any individual so excused for the purposes of the investigation.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 23 mins (2003-09-04 15:47:17 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
More examples (basically, I\'ve searched Google using the string:
\"board of inquiry + scientific + misconduct\" and found more than 300 entries):
http://www.stthomasu.ca/research/Research/Researchintegrityp...
...
3. To determine that the substance of the allegation may be a serious act of misconduct and, establish a \"Board of Inquiry\" to conduct a formal investigation.
http://www.bcit.ca/~presoff/6600.htm
B. Investigating Allegations of Misconduct in Research
...
B.6.2 The Dean, Applied Research shall receive submissions and consult with whatever other parties he/she deems necessary, and within 30 days of receiving the Respondent\'s submission shall submit a report to the Vice-President recommending whether or not the Complaint should proceed to a formal Board of Inquiry. Copies of the Dean\'s report shall be made available to the Complainant and Respondent.
Reference:
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "It would have perhaps been more helpful if I'd pointed out that this is
a Russian using a familar Russian term talking about a case of scientific
fraud in the US. I think Kirill's answer sounds on the money and is specific
to this case, not to mention being well-documented, as usual! :-)"
+6
5 mins
Ethics Committee; Board of Ethics
I guess that's what it is...
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Vladimir Pochinov
: That's it!
2 mins
|
thank you, Vladimir
|
|
agree |
Oleg Pashuk (X)
2 hrs
|
thank you, Oleg
|
|
agree |
nrabate
3 hrs
|
agree |
Leah Aharoni
4 hrs
|
agree |
Sergey Strakhov
5 hrs
|
thank you all
|
|
agree |
Mark Vaintroub
3 days 3 hrs
|
7 mins
Russian term (edited):
��� �����
peer review board
I think it would do nice for non-military contexts. "(Officers) court of honor" would fit best in the military contexts. The name here implies an inquiry by peers...
Peer Review Board was created to serve the LC community by resolving student conduct matters ...
www.lclark.edu/~aslc/prb/
Peer Review Board was created to serve the LC community by resolving student conduct matters ...
www.lclark.edu/~aslc/prb/
14 mins
comrade's court or court of fellow workers
if you necessarily want to avoid "Court of honor" (Re.: Russian-English Dictionary over 160 000 words & expressions, 1997, ISBN 5-200-02419, Russian-English Dictionary, 34 000 words approx., Arakin, Soviet Encyclopedia Publ. House, Moscow, 1970). Or continuing xeni's idea Commission on /(Scientific) Ethics. Good luck in inquiring the case, GaryG!
Something went wrong...